Monday, April 29, 2019

George Harrison - George Harrison (1969)


The Beatles' self-titled double album was released in November 22nd, 1968 by Apple Records. It was very important for a number of reasons: it was the group's first (and only) double LP, and began a trend that saw band members collaborating less and less while working on songs, leading to some calling the record "four solo albums at once". Most significantly, it signaled a very sharp increase in the quality of George's output, with his While My Guitar Gently Weeps rivaling most of John and Paul's tunes on the record, and even being considered the best track on it by some. The problem for Harrison, however, was that the rest of the band didn't seem to catch on to that, and he felt rather sidelined when there came the time to contribute material, only getting two or three songs out while Lennon & McCartney dominated their output. To further his discontent, after the release of the album, George visited Bob Dylan and The Band in their country home of Woodstock, NY, and became rather impressed by their communal and democratic style of writing and recording, with everyone getting an equal say. The trip also saw a great burst of creativity for him, penning a couple of songs during and shortly after it, as well as even co-writing two songs with Bob Dylan, who was seemingly pretty impressed by Hari's songwriting back then.

So it must have been quite the reality shock for the guitarist to return home and play with the Beatles again during the Get Back sessions, that January. He had stockpiled a rather large amount of tunes, between the Woodstock trip and then, but saw his songs once more being ignored in favor of subpar material, such as Maxwell's Silver Hammer and Dig a Pony. To add insult to injury, he had to suffer through thousands of takes of the duo's songs, while his were met with subpar performances and half-assed attempts at best, even when the tune in question was much better than what they had to offer. Things came to a point that after a week of sessions, he quit the band on January 10, citing the endless takes and perfectionism of Paul, their ignoring of his material, and the fact they were being filmed as the prime reasons for that. They managed to coax him back a couple of days afterward, but the seed of his detachment of the band was already there. As such, he and Lennon discussed plans of him making a solo album that year, to "let all those songs out", and not having to worry about them not being recorded by the Beatles, something which Lennon encouraged and approved of. The rest of the Get Back sessions went by without much more tensions between him and the band, as he had become quite detached and bored by then, only contributing the bare minimum.

His plans for a solo record, however, didn't seem to go much further than that brainstorming session in mid-January. By February, the Beatles had gotten back to recording together the usual way, with much less tension than before. The fact John got into a car accident sometime around then made it necessary that George and Paul collaborated a lot more than usual, and they did so in good terms. A good example of the collaboration between the two being Paul's superb bass playing in Something, which was the first A-side Beatles single written by him. It was a very popular track, and it even managed to get to the Top 5 in the American singles chart, getting almost universal acclaim alongside Here Comes the Sun, his other song on the album. If there was any doubt of George's growth and excellence as a songwriter by then, it was all but eliminated with the release of those two fantastic tracks. After the release of the album, however, Lennon privately announced he was leaving the group, and the band proceeded to splinter. George went and toured with Delaney & Bonnie and Friends, him already being a pretty big fan of the duo and their backing band, those being his first live performances since 1966, and finally decided to make his first solo album, recording and releasing the majestic All Things Must Pass album in 1970.

However, what you might have figured out I'd ask is: what if he had made a solo album in mid-1969? If he had followed suit with his plans to record a solo LP with all the songs he had stacked by then, what would that look like? Well, to figure that out, we need to set some ground rules first. The first one would be of a "deadline" to when the album's songs can be written, or at least begun. That deadline would be sometime in August 1969, which is right before the Beatles disbanded and he went on tour with Delaney and Bonnie, that signaling the end of his November 1968 begun writing streak. Also because of that, For You Blue won't be considered as a contender for the record, as it was already recorded with the Beatles for the Let it Be album by then, and we will focus on the February/August period for recording, that putting the album's release sometime in November. The album would most likely feature some 10/12 songs, considering the standard length of the albums back then and the amount/quality of songs he had. Such a record would absolutely feature his two Abbey Road tunes, as I think he'd want to give his solo career the best shot possible, and give something more subpar like Window Window to them in order to still contribute to the band. Anyway, without extending this any further than we already have, here's our tracklist:

What is Life (All Things Must Pass)
Something (Abbey Road)
All Things Must Pass (All Things Must Pass)
Old Brown Shoe (Past Masters)
Behind that Locked Door (All Things Must Pass)
Isn't it a Pity? (All Things Must Pass)
-
Here Comes the Sun (Abbey Road)
Wah Wah (All Things Must Pass)
Let it Down (All Things Must Pass)
The Art of Dying (All Things Must Pass)
Run of the Mill (All Things Must Pass)
Hear Me Lord (All Things Must Pass)

Bonus tracks:
I Me Mine (Let it Be... Naked)
I'd Have You Anytime (All Things Must Pass)
Window, Window (Beware of ABKCO)

George playing in Apple Studios, January 1969

Considering the amount of breathtaking classics he had available back then, it's honestly not too hard to make a great album out of this, and what I first decided on was the opening and closing tunes for each side. The obvious choices were ending the sides with "the epics", namely Isn't it a Pity and Hear Me Lord, and beginning side two with catchy upbeat Here Comes the Sun. The album opener was a more complicated choice, but What is Life with its long instrumental intro, upbeat nature and even "welcoming" feel, make it a pretty natural opener. From then on, I tried to fill out the middle with what I considered the best tracks on the record, while spacing out the Beatles tunes as much as possible. Right out of the gate, I was able to exclude both Window, Window and I Me Mine, as neither were considered by George for release back then, with IMM only being brought back to fill the Let it Be album. So we end up with nine songs to fill eight possible slots, with either Old Brown Shoe or I'd Have You Anytime getting the boot. I, unfortunately, went with the latter, as Old Brown Shoe manages to serve as a more upbeat fun track, which this album, aside from WIL, HCTS and Wah Wah, seriously lacks. However, I still see fit for it to be used as a non-album b-side, for it to not be wasted, or even a single if George is feeling audacious.

A small change that would make one hell of a difference to the ATMP tracks is the lack of Phil Spector on the producer's chair. Instead of him, it would have most certainly been produced by George himself, with orchestrations and co-production by his friend John Barham, who co-produced his Wonderwall LP as well. As a result, the album would probably have a much more stripped down and cleaner sound, more akin to the Abbey Road LP than Spector's reverb-laden Wall of Sound. The personnel would also change a bit, as he hadn't met Delaney & Bonnie and Friends by then yet, so no Jim Gordon, Carl Radle, Bobby Whitlock, and no horns. It would most likely consist of the rest of the ATMP personnel, minus Badfinger and plus some other big names at the time like Nicky Hopkins, only this time not playing all at once on the same song. Another big difference in the album's sound would be that Harrison only started developing his now trademark slide technique during the D&B tour, so it would too be absent here. Instead, the predominant guitar sound would most likely be the Leslie speaker combo he premiered on Cream's Badge and used all through 1969. Another change is that some of the songs, most notably Wah Wah, probably wouldn't be as overlong, since we're not talking about a double album anymore, and some editing would be needed to make this fit into two sides.

Regarding the arrangements, What is Life would feature more or less the same arrangement, perhaps without the horns and more prominent backing vocals. Something would hopefully keep its arrangement, and since Paul and George were in good terms back then, I can even see him guesting on bass on this track, preserving its iconic bassline in here. Next up is All Things Must Pass, which would most likely feature more prominent harmonies and none of those distracting horn parts, sounding more like the Band-inspired track that it actually is. Old Brown Shoe would sound more or less like it does now, as would the Band-soundalike Behind that Locked Door, being the last-written track on the record. Isn't it a Pity would sound pretty much like the 2nd version of it on the 1970 album, providing a great end to side one. Here Comes the Sun remains untouched, and Wah Wah would probably get its reverb washed out and get shortened by a good minute and a half. Getting rid of the horns and orchestration would be good too! Let it Down would probably keep its bombastic nature and great orchestral arrangement, while The Art of Dying would exchange its mariachi band thing for a more guitar fuzz-led arrangement. Run of the Mill stays the same, as it too already sounds like a great stripped down track, and Hear Me Lord would probably just tone down on the reverb, while keeping its epicness intact.

This album would be titled simply George Harrison, I think, and to further represent that, the cover is simply a picture of him from April 1969 with his name superimposed at the top. The album clocks in at almost 50 minutes, and would most certainly have Something as it's lead single, followed perhaps by Here Comes the Sun. Commercially, it would no doubt perform pretty darn well, as it was the first real solo album by a Beatle, and before the band even broke up per se. And as for its impact on the breakup, I don't think it would have much impact, since John would already have quit the group even before this record hit the stores. The change I can see happening is that this album, not McCartney six months later, is followed by the breakup announcement and following acrimony and sorrow. As for critical acclaim, I don't think any album with this caliber of songwriting, cast, and performance could be considered weak, and the press at the time would certainly be as surprised and overjoyed by the album as they were by All Things Must Pass. The thing this lacks, for good or bad, is the sheer scope and message that releasing the triple album we all know and love had, showing everyone just how good of an artist he was. But for all the epicness and sheer magnitude this misses, it compensates with simplicity and ease not found on the original, showing you just how much difference a year can make. 

Sources:
- George Harrison - All Things Must Pass
- The Beatles - Abbey Road
- The Beatles - Past Masters
- The Beatles - Let it Be... Naked
- George Harrison - Beware of ABKCO (bootleg)

17 comments:

  1. Just as a curiosity, here's when each song was composed:

    Isn't it a Pity - mid 1966
    The Art of Dying - late 1966
    Something - November 1968
    I'd Have You Anytime - November 1968
    All Things Must Pass - November 1968
    Let it Down - December 1968
    Old Brown Shoe - January 1969
    Hear Me Lord - January 1969
    Window, Window - January 1969
    I Me Mine - January 1969
    Wah Wah - January 1969
    Run of the Mill - February 1969
    Here Comes the Sun - April 1969
    What is Life - May 1969
    Behind that Locked Door - August 1969

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When was Beware of Darkness Written, I always thought that it was sometime in 1969?

      Delete
    2. Beware of Darkness was written in January 1970, if I'm not mistaken, right after the Delaney and Bonnie tour. It wasn't from '69, although it surely sounds a lot like his songs from that period!

      Delete
    3. Many thanks for your reply. I guess the song would have to be considered as being a post Beatles song therefore even though it sounds like a Beatles era composition from the sensational summer of 1969.

      Delete
  2. Very nice. He had enough for a solo album in '68. It would be interesting to hear some of these songs stripped of the Spector production. I think he still might have gave Old Brown Shoe and the Abbey Road songs to the but a great what if idea.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Absolutely,I decided on him keeping Something/Here Comes the Sun and giving Window Window/I Me Mine in order to make the best album possible out of this. But he had enough stuff for more than a couple records, by 1970.

      Delete
  3. Very nice, would have been a cool album. Would love to hear the ATMP songs without Spector's awful production. Wasn't fond of the way the Delaney & Bonnie folks played on it either. Would have preferred Ringo & Klaus throughout.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll admit Spector's stuff is an acquired taste, but once you get used to it, it becomes part of the charm of the album. I honestly can't picture the ATMP album without it, for good or bad.

      Delete
    2. I guess I'll never acquire that. I just don't like his production style at all, for anyone. Having all the bootlegs, and hearing the songs , even in an unfinished state " unSpectorized ", I like them so much better. Harrison had talked about redoing the album and removing that production before he died, but alas never got to it. Keep up your posts, they are always very interesting.

      Delete
    3. I guess to each his own, but not even his Ronettes stuff? And thanks a lot, by the way!

      Delete
  4. Having just heard it for myself, I must say it gels really well. I'd personally remove the Beatles songs and re-insert "I'd Have You Anytime" so this and Abbey Road (plus Let It Be) can exist as separate entities.

    But what about the remaining All Things Must Pass tracks? Well, with a little help from some extra tracks, I managed to compile an album I dubbed The Magic is Here Again, after a working title for Living in the Material World:

    Beware of Darkness
    My Sweet Lord
    Deep Blue
    If Not for You
    Bangla Desh

    I Dig Love
    Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let It Roll)
    Apple Scruffs
    I Live for You
    Awaiting on You All

    Personally, I could see it for an August 1971 release with "Bangla Desh" and "Deep Blue" as last-minute inclusions. Still, a great album nonetheless.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! I was wondering about the same thing yesterday, actually! I'd actually go with a late-1970 release date, and keep Bangladesh as a standalone single.

      Still haven't decided on a tracklist, but the songlist is basically that, plus Beautiful Girl, Rocking Chair in Hawaii, and Woman Don't You Cry for Me. If I come up with something, I'll make sure to send it to you!

      Delete
    2. Well, I promised I'd come back with a tracklist!

      George Harrison - The Magic is Here Again (1970)

      Woman Don't You Cry for Me (Thirty Three & 1/3)
      My Sweet Lord (All Things Must Pass)
      Beautiful Girl (Thirty Three & 1/3)
      Awaiting on You All (All Things Must Pass)
      I Live for You (All Things Must Pass)
      Try Some, Buy Some (Living in the Material World)
      -
      Beware of Darkness (All Things Must Pass)
      Apple Scruffs (All Things Must Pass)
      Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (All Things Must Pass)
      You (Extra Texture - Read All About It)
      Rocking Chair in Hawaii (Brainwashed)
      When Every Song is Sung (ATMP Outtake)

      Delete
  5. I really, really like the cover. And the song choices are great to. I do believe that if the band split sooner or used different songs, he wouldve made this. Maybe even Pigges wouldve been redone on this. Like what Ringo did at one point

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey, thanks! But why Piggies specifically? I think he'd probably redo Circles and Not Guilty instead, seen as they're good songs and weren't actually released back then :D

      Delete
  6. Curious, with the remasters that have come since you composed this, what sources would you now recommend for these tracks, as I do believe the 50th ann'y ATMP covers the Beware Of ABKO bootleg as well. I have my own source for the LIB...N tracks that isn't LIB...N.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've since revised the tracklist, but I found the 50th Anniversary remixes of ATMP really atrocious. Especially "Let it Down", they managed to butcher that one beyond belief.

      I instead just gave up and used the regular Spector mixes, but you *could* try using alternate takes throughout. Take 1 of "Let it Down" has an awesome, Abbey Road-like feel, as do some outtakes of "Art of Dying" and "Hear Me Lord". Enough for a full album? I don't know, but worth giving a try.

      Here's the revised tracklist, also:

      What is Life? (All Things Must Pass)
      Something (Abbey Road)
      The Art of Dying (All Things Must Pass)
      All Things Must Pass (All Things Must Pass)
      Isn't it a Pity? (All Things Must Pass)
      -
      Here Comes the Sun (Abbey Road)
      Wah-Wah (All Things Must Pass)
      Let it Down (All Things Must Pass)
      Run of the Mill (All Things Must Pass)
      Hear Me Lord (All Things Must Pass)

      I find that ten tracks is more than enough, and "Old Brown Shoe" is given back to the Beatles. His last release with them, if you will. "Isn't it a Pity?" is the seven minute version, making sure this is a 40-plus minute album.

      Delete